Reverse Osmosis Waste Water: What Sets Your Drain Flow and How to Cut It

Direct Purchase Available

NH2O-BW400RG2

Your RO's drain flow got decided on the day somebody drew the array. The concentrate valve on the front panel can move it, but only inside limits the array sets, and that matters when you go looking for savings on the water bill.

Take a commercial system built on one pressure vessel with four 8040 elements, 400 square feet each, running on well water at 18 gfd. It makes 28,800 gallons a day of permeate, 20 gpm; to keep the arithmetic simple, say each element makes the same 5 gpm. DuPont's design guidelines for that well water allow the last element to recover at most 19 percent of what flows into it, so the tail element needs at least 26 gpm of feed, and about 21 gpm leaves as concentrate. That's roughly 30,700 gallons a day out the concentrate line, and recovery near 48 percent. If your sewer charge follows your water use, every one of those gallons gets paid for twice. Closing the concentrate valve a turn looks like the fix. Do that and you can scale the tail elements before the savings add up.

The number is calculable though, and once you've run the arithmetic below you'll know whether your system has room to improve or whether it's already against the wall.

Recovery is the number, everything else is bookkeeping

Recovery is permeate flow divided by feed flow. Concentrate is whatever's left, so recovery and reject always add to 100 percent. Any "3 to 1 waste ratio" you read is somebody restating a recovery figure in a different unit.

What matters on a bill is gallons of feed per 1,000 gallons of product:

System recoveryFeed per 1,000 gal permeateTo drain per 1,000 gal permeateConcentration factor
50%2,000 gal1,000 gal2.0x
60%1,667 gal667 gal2.5x
70%1,429 gal429 gal3.3x
75%1,333 gal333 gal4.0x
80%1,250 gal250 gal5.0x

That last column decides whether you're allowed to move down the table. Concentration factor is 1 divided by (1 minus recovery), and it tells you how many times over the rejected salts pile up in the concentrate stream. Going from 50 percent to 80 percent recovery cuts your drain flow by three quarters and raises the concentration factor from 2.0 to 5.0 at the same time.

The tail element puts a floor under the drain flow

Every 8040 element needs a minimum flow leaving it, and DuPont publishes that number, with a maximum recovery per element, as a recommended design guideline for each kind of feed water. The concentrate stream is what sweeps rejected salts off the membrane surface, so it has a job to do besides leaving. Push an element past those limits and the concentration at the membrane face climbs past what your feed analysis predicts.

For a 400 or 440 square foot brackish element on well water at SDI under 3, DuPont's minimum concentrate flow is 13 gpm and maximum element recovery is 19 percent. On conventionally pretreated surface water at SDI under 5 it tightens to 15 gpm and 15 percent. On conventionally treated wastewater it's 16 gpm and 13 percent. The design flux range for that well water case is 16 to 20 gfd, and maximum feed flow into a 400 square foot element is 75 gpm. DuPont calls these guidelines and says a moderate violation for a short time may be acceptable, as long as the maximum pressure drop and maximum feed pressure on the element's datasheet aren't exceeded.

Now put those numbers back into the single-vessel system from the top. Four elements at 18 gfd give you 20 gpm of permeate, 5 gpm from the tail element. At 19 percent, that tail element needs 26 gpm of feed, so about 21 gpm leaves the vessel and recovery lands near 48 percent. In a real vessel the tail element makes less than the lead one, so the figure lands somewhat higher, but in a straight pass through one vessel no valve position or pump moves it far without pushing the tail element past those guidelines, because the tail element's limits take a large share of the whole feed. DuPont's manual puts one stage of six-element vessels at 40 to 60 percent recovery, and notes that a one-stage system can go higher if part of the concentrate is recycled.

Add a second stage and the arithmetic opens up. A 2 to 1 array, two vessels feeding one, six elements each, makes 80 gpm of permeate at 16 gfd, four times as much permeate stacked against the same tail-element limits. DuPont's manual puts brackish systems with 12 elements in series, in two stages, at 70 to 80 percent recovery. Staging is the whole trick: the tail vessel keeps its crossflow while the front of the array does the volume.

Feed chemistry sets the ceiling above that floor

Hydraulics tell you the most recovery your array can reach inside the design guidelines. Your water tells you how much of that you're allowed to use.

At 75 percent recovery everything rejected is four times more concentrated in the reject than in the feed. A feed carrying 25 mg/L of reactive silica arrives at the tail at 100 mg/L. Push to 80 percent and it's 125 mg/L. The silica solubility chart in DuPont's FilmTec manual reads about 125 mg/L at 25 degrees C, lower in colder water, so a feed at 25 mg/L hits the silica wall around 80 percent recovery at 25 degrees C and near-neutral concentrate pH (DuPont adds a correction for pH). What's the reactive silica on your last well analysis? If silica scale does form, DuPont lists a high-pH caustic clean for it, and warns that acid cleaners can react with silica and make the decline worse.

Hydranautics publishes the saturation limits its design software alarms on, calculated in the concentrate stream where 100 percent means normal solubility with no antiscalant. Calcium carbonate alarms at an LSI of positive 1.8, and chemical suppliers have reported their antiscalants working above that. Calcium sulfate alarms at 230 percent of saturation, strontium sulfate at 800 percent, barium sulfate at 6,000 percent, silica at 100 percent. With acid feed alone, Hydranautics recommends a concentrate LSI of negative 0.2. That gap between negative 0.2 and positive 1.8 is what a correctly dosed antiscalant program buys you. Your chemical supplier's projection will show how many recovery points it's worth on your water.

What moves the number, in the order worth trying

Start with the antiscalant, because it raises the chemistry ceiling without new equipment. Get a current full feed analysis to your chemical supplier, including barium measured to 10 ppb (Hydranautics' guidance), strontium and reactive silica, and let their program set the dose and the maximum recovery. Then acid feed, if carbonate rather than sulfate or silica is what's binding you.

After that comes array work, and that's a real project: new vessels, new piping and a shutdown long enough to install them. Would a second stage need a bigger feed pump in your plant? Ask whoever designs it before you price it. Concentrate recirculation is the cheaper cousin: pipe part of the reject back to the feed side so the vessel keeps its crossflow while less water leaves the system. DuPont's manual lists the cost: higher power consumption, 15 to 20 percent, and higher system salt passage, because the feed the elements see carries more salt.

Reuse is another option. RO reject at 60 percent recovery carries 2.5 times the feed TDS. Could it serve as cooling tower makeup, wash-down or irrigation water? Chlorides, conductivity, hardness and silica all have to clear the receiving system's limits, and the reject carries your antiscalant with it, so ask your tower chemical supplier about compatibility before you plumb it. Ask your utility too, whether sending less volume at higher TDS changes your discharge charges.

The failure that looks like water savings

Someone closes the concentrate throttle to bring the drain flow down. The flow meter reads lower, recovery reads higher, and at first it looks like a win.

Inside the tail element, crossflow dropped and element recovery jumped past the design guideline. Concentration at the membrane face climbs, salts precipitate where the sweep is weakest, and scale starts building in the last stage. DuPont's troubleshooting guide says scaling usually starts in the last stage and moves gradually upstream, and that waters high in calcium, bicarbonate or sulfate can scale a system within hours. You'll see it as differential pressure creeping up on the tail end while permeate conductivity drifts up too, and normalized permeate flow falls off. The same guide says to weigh a tail element, because scaled elements are heavy.

The tell arrives before the damage gets worse, if somebody's logging. Element pressure drop is capped at 15 psi per element and 50 psi per vessel on DuPont's FilmTec BW30 PRO-400. A normalized pressure drop up 10 to 15 percent over its clean baseline is one of DuPont's cleaning triggers, alongside a 10 percent drop in normalized permeate flow and a 5 to 10 percent rise in normalized salt passage.

Where to spend the money

Run the tail-element arithmetic first. If your array is a single stage with no concentrate recycle, its hydraulics hold your recovery down, and chemistry or valve work won't move it far without breaking the tail-element guidelines, so the question becomes whether a second stage or recirculation pencils out. On a 28,800 gpd system in McAllen, Texas, where the city's rate for commercial customers is $3.15 per 1,000 gallons, moving from about 48 to 75 percent recovery saves about 730 gallons of feed per 1,000 gallons of product, about $24,000 a year on the water side alone if it runs every day, before you count sewer. Plug in your own rate and run days. If your array already has stages, look at the chemistry: a current feed analysis and the antiscalant program are where the next points come from.

The array sets your recovery, and the element you load into it has to live inside the same limits. On the current datasheets, the NanoH2O (formerly LG) BW 400 R G2 and the FilmTec BW30 PRO-400 share a 75 gpm maximum feed flow and a 15 psi maximum pressure drop per element. They differ on the feed spacer, 34 mil on the G2, which NanoH2O sells as its low differential pressure design, against 28 mil, and on rated output: 11,500 gpd and 99.8 percent stabilized rejection against 11,000 gpd and 99.6 percent, at 2,000 ppm NaCl and 225 psi (pH 7 on NanoH2O's sheet, pH 8 on DuPont's). NanoH2O's datasheet lists reduced differential pressure as a feature but gives no figure for how much the thicker spacer lowers it, so your own stage ΔP log is the test of it.

Replacing elements in a commercial array? The NanoH2O BW 400 R G2 page shows the price and volume tiers: 5% off at 5 to 9 units and 10% off at 10 or more, per model. We're an authorized NanoH2O distributor, and orders placed and paid by 1 PM Central on a business day ship the same day. Not sure which element fits your system? Ask Crystal Claire, our sales engineer, in the chat on our site.

Related reading: Brackish Water Reverse Osmosis: Why Feed Chemistry Sets Your Recovery Limit · Reverse Osmosis Antiscalant: How the Dose Gets Set, and How the Program Fails

Sources

#CommercialRO#SystemDesign#OperatingCosts

Procurement

Visit Retail Shop

Newsletter

Get practical water treatment guides in your inbox

Field-tested insights on membranes, filtration, and system design. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.